After a highly politicized and contentious election, Donald Trump will officially become the 47th president of the USA. Many organizations fear what the future of DEI will look like under a Trump presidency, given his strong anti-immigration stance and fight against the "woke mind virus" in a divisive culture war. As political shifts impact business environments, maintaining a commitment to diversity, equity, and inclusion is more critical than ever.

Tighter Immigration Laws

One of President Trump's major campaign promises centered on strengthening borders and increasing deportations. We can anticipate immediate actions to close the border and enhance immigration enforcement on his first day in office. This approach is expected to lead to a surge in enforcement raids by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and a significant increase in Form I-9 audits.

During Donald Trump's last year in office, ICE conducted nearly 12,000 I-9 audits alone. This is a substantial amount compared to the approximately 400 audits under the Joe Biden administration. This increase reflects a more aggressive stance on verifying employment eligibility and enforcing immigration laws. Employers found non-compliant with I-9 requirements may face severe penalties, including fines and potential criminal charges.

The anticipated escalation in enforcement activities poses challenges for organizations striving to maintain diverse and inclusive workplaces. Stricter immigration laws and intensified enforcement can create an atmosphere of uncertainty and fear among employees, particularly those from immigrant backgrounds. This environment may hinder open communication, collaboration, and overall morale within the workforce.

“In times of political change, it’s important for organizations to reaffirm their commitment to diversity and inclusion. These values are not tied to any political ideology; they are about creating workplaces where everyone can contribute to their fullest potential.” – Betsy Bagley, Co-Founder

Expect DEI-Adjacent Legal Battles

Under President Trump's administration, companies can anticipate increased legal challenges related to DEI initiatives. The Supreme Court's decision to end affirmative action in June 2023 emboldened conservative groups to file complaints and lawsuits against organizations implementing DEI programs.

Notably, the America First Legal Foundation has been at the forefront of these efforts. The foundation is led by former Trump adviser Stephen Miller and has filed numerous lawsuits aimed at reversing DEI policies.

Legal experts suggest that the recent election outcome could provide more funding and resources to conservative litigants like Miller and Edward Blum, who have long opposed race-based admissions in higher education. This shift may lead to increased scrutiny of corporate DEI initiatives, with potential legal battles on the horizon.

One area of concern is the legality of race-conscious hiring and promotion practices. Companies implementing such policies may face lawsuits alleging reverse discrimination. For instance, IBM faced a lawsuit from a former white employee claiming he was terminated to fulfill diversity goals.

Companies may also encounter legal challenges related to DEI training programs. Some argue that certain training materials promote divisive concepts, leading to potential lawsuits claiming that such programs create a hostile work environment.

To mitigate these risks, organizations are conducting thorough audits of their DEI policies to ensure compliance with current laws. Legal experts advise companies to review their DEI initiatives carefully, focusing on creating inclusive environments without implementing policies that could be perceived as discriminatory.

Training employees on how to discuss and implement inclusive employment practices is also crucial. Public statements about DEI can be scrutinized and potentially lead to legal claims or social media backlash. That’s why companies are becoming more cautious about their external communications regarding DEI.

The evolving legal landscape under the Trump administration necessitates that companies remain vigilant and proactive in reviewing and adjusting their DEI policies.

Be Ready to Defend and Advocate for Your DEI Initiatives

This moment presents an opportunity for DEI to refocus on what truly matters: creating workplaces where everyone can thrive and deliver their full potential. Building inclusive organizations isn’t optional—it’s a business imperative. Companies that fail to prioritize inclusion risk falling behind in the competition for the best talent. We anticipate that organizations will continue their inclusion initiatives with a sharper focus. Programs are likely to evolve, becoming more analytical and action-oriented, emphasizing measurable outcomes and strategies that maximize the "return on inclusion." The future of DEI will be about impact, not just intent.

There’s no doubt Trump’s election victory will embolden anti-DEI efforts across the country. Conservative activists, such as Robby Starbuck, have intensified campaigns against corporate DEI programs, pressuring companies to abandon these efforts. This climate means organizations actively advocate and defend their DEI commitments.

A key strategy is to ensure that DEI initiatives are deeply integrated into the organization's core values and operations. This involves articulating the tangible benefits of DEI, such as enhanced innovation, improved employee engagement, and better financial performance. By demonstrating how DEI contributes to business success, companies can build a compelling case for its importance.

“DEI must be positioned as a business imperative, not a political one. Organizations that lead with data and measurable outcomes will be better equipped to defend their initiatives and show their undeniable value to both employees and shareholders.” – Pedro do Carmo Costa, Co-Founder

Leadership plays a crucial role in this advocacy. Executives must be prepared to publicly support DEI initiatives, addressing criticisms with data-driven arguments that highlight the positive impact of diversity and inclusion on the organization's goals. This unified stance can help mitigate external pressures and reinforce the company's commitment to DEI. 

To make these advocacy efforts less fraught and resisted, more than half of companies report modifying the language they use to refer to DEI. They’re opting to drop “diversity” or “equity” from the terminology to avoid criticism and backlash.

Another vital component is employee engagement in inclusion efforts. Providing platforms for employees to share their experiences and perspectives can foster a more inclusive culture. Training programs that emphasize the value of inclusion and equip employees with tools to navigate complex conversations are essential. Such initiatives not only promote understanding but also empower employees to become advocates for DEI within and outside the organization.

Transparency and accountability are also critical. Regularly communicating DEI goals, progress, and challenges to all stakeholders can build trust and demonstrate a genuine commitment to these values. Establishing metrics to assess the effectiveness of DEI initiatives allows organizations to make informed adjustments and showcase successes.

Data is also a key component. Data can reveal the very real problems that exist and demonstrate why DEI initiatives are necessary. Data can also track the positive changes that result.  In this challenging environment, leveraging specialized tools can provide a significant advantage. Plus, partnering with experts in DEI and compliance can provide organizations with the right insights needed to adapt to the evolving landscape. 

With Pulsely, companies assess their current DEI status, identify areas for improvement, and develop strategies to foster an inclusive culture amidst political and regulatory changes. In fact, many of Pulsely's clients have added a citizenship demographic question in their surveys to identify and close any inclusion gaps experienced by these employee segments. 

Ready to learn how Pulsely can transform your DEI approach? Contact us today or book your demo to learn how Pulsely’s science-based solution can help you build a more inclusive workplace. Remember, building inclusive organizations is not a political agenda, it’s a business agenda!

‍