Collecting employee data is fundamental to successful DEI initiatives. Organizations can identify gaps and foster inclusive environments by understanding how aspects like race, gender, and religion impact the workplace experiences of their employees. However, capturing and analyzing this kind of data needs careful attention; data privacy and security aren't just ethical considerations but a legal obligation. Mishandling sensitive information can lead to compliance risks and erode employee trust.

Here are 10 essential things you need to know to collect sensitive employee data successfully.

1. Understand the Legal Framework of Your Region

Employee data collection rules vary significantly by region, requiring organizations to adapt accordingly.

• European Union: Under GDPR, collecting sensitive data like race or ethnicity is generally prohibited unless specific conditions are met. For instance, Belgian law doesn’t mandate such data collection, but it’s not outright prohibited. Conversely, in France, both constitutional and data protection laws strongly restrict processing racial or ethnic data unless for specific exemptions like explicit consent or public interest purposes.
• United Kingdom: The UK GDPR, aligned with the Data Protection Act 2018, governs employee data protection. Organizations must ensure transparency, obtain explicit consent, and demonstrate necessity when handling sensitive information.
• Canada: PIPEDA regulates federally, while some provinces, like British Columbia and Alberta, enforce their privacy laws. Employers must differentiate rules based on industry and jurisdiction while safeguarding employee rights.
• United States: There is no overarching federal law for employee data protection. Instead, a combination of laws like the ADA, FCRA, and state-specific legislation governs data collection. However, many companies in the US do collect data that fall under the terms of GDPR and therefore need to know about and comply with it. Companies must navigate this complex patchwork to remain compliant.

2. Anonymous vs. Confidential Surveys: Key Differences

Anonymous and confidential surveys each offer distinct benefits for employee data collection. Anonymous surveys do not link survey responses to individuals. This means that either the project does not collect identifying information of individual persons (e.g., name, address, email address, etc.), or the project cannot link individual responses with participants’ identities. While this approach prioritizes privacy, it limits follow-ups and the ability to verify data accuracy. For example, in anonymous surveys, self-reported data about a department or level might lack precision. Choosing the right approach depends on organizational goals and the desired depth of analysis.

In confidential surveys, only the investigator(s) can identify the responses of individual participants. For example, Pulsely’s approach allows data collection through individualized email links, enabling employers to track response rates, send reminders only to non-respondents, and connect survey data with HR records. 

This distinction reflects the methodology we use and recommend – since it provides actionable insights and safeguards employee trust – though it’s not a standard approach across industry.

3. Leverage Third-Party Providers for Sensitive Data

Third-party providers bridge the gap between privacy regulations and diversity initiatives by ensuring sensitive data is collected and stored securely. Many jurisdictions, such as those under GDPR, permit the collection of sensitive data – like race or ethnicity – if handled anonymously through external platforms. This enables organizations to meet non-discrimination goals while adhering to privacy laws.

“When organizations use third-party platforms like Pulsely, they not only ensure compliance but also build trust by maintaining employee confidentiality. Working with experts ensures sensitive data supports DEI strategies without compromising workers’ privacy or violating legal frameworks.” – Pedro do Carmo Costa, Co-Founder.

4. Clarify the Purpose and Benefits of Data Collection

Transparency about the purpose of data collection builds trust and encourages participation. Employees need to know how their data will be used to drive inclusion and benefit the workforce. According to the European Commission's Equality of Data Handbook: "Any employee being asked to provide data should be given a full explanation of the reasons for collecting the data, the importance of providing a response, how the data will be used, and arrangements made for keeping the information secure and confidential."

Data collection is about compliance and driving inclusive policies that empower employees. Transparency ensures employees feel valued and protected.

5. Get Informed/Explicit Consent and Only Collect Relevant Data

Collecting diversity data often serves dual purposes: legal compliance and fulfilling corporate social responsibility. However, obtaining informed and explicit consent from employees requires careful navigation. Under the GDPR, consent must be “freely given, specific, informed, and unambiguous.” Due to workplace power dynamics, ensuring truly voluntary consent can be challenging.

Employers must also adhere to data minimization principles, collecting only what is strictly necessary for a specified purpose. Conducting a data protection impact assessment (DPIA) helps organizations evaluate risks and focus on relevance. This builds trust and minimizes overreach while aligning with legal and ethical standards.

6. Take Location and Culture into Account

Cultural norms and legal frameworks surrounding DEI data collection vary widely by region. In some countries, local labor laws or social norms may shape what data employees are comfortable sharing. Legal counsel and DEI leaders must stay informed about both existing legislation and cultural sensitivities.

Clear communication is also crucial. Employees should understand what data is being collected, why it matters, and how it will benefit them.

"Building trust requires messaging that emphasizes respect for the employee’s willingness to share their identifiers and clarifies who has access to their data. . Accountability for action and transparent communication ensure employees feel confident that sharing their information will benefit them." – Betsy Bagley, Co-Founder

7. Have Clear and Relevant Written Policies

Written policies are essential for consistent execution and compliance with DEI initiatives. Organizations should implement a Written Information Security Program to outline how personal data – DEI-related information included – is handled.

Clear documentation supports compliance and fosters accountability. It provides a framework for training personnel, monitoring processes, and addressing violations. Developing strong written policies demonstrates a commitment to data security and reinforces the organization’s dedication to ethical practices in DEI efforts.

8. Don’t Neglect Data Security

Data breaches and phishing scams targeting employee information are increasingly common, making robust security safeguards essential. While U.S. laws often prioritize financial or health information, DEI-related data, such as race or gender, presents equally significant privacy concerns. In jurisdictions like the EU, stricter regulations require organizations to protect such sensitive data.

Including DEI data in a Written Information Security Program demonstrates a commitment to privacy and builds trust with employees. When people see their data is handled securely, they are more likely to participate, ensuring the success of DEI initiatives. Security measures also reduce the risk of breaches, protecting the organization from reputational harm.

9. Follow the “Less is More” Principle

In data collection, restraint often leads to better outcomes. Retaining only essential data reduces the risk of breaches, streamlines analysis, and ensures compliance with privacy laws. For example, some organizations may feel tempted to retain extensive demographic data indefinitely. However, without a clear purpose or expiration timeline, this practice creates unnecessary liabilities.

Adopt a strategic approach: collect only the data needed for specific DEI goals and implement retention policies to delete outdated or irrelevant data. Streamlined data practices build trust and demonstrate the organization’s respect for employee privacy.

10. Keep Surveys Inclusive, Unbiased, and Relevant

Survey design matters. Inclusive phrasing increases participation rates and ensures accurate insights. For example, asking employees about whether they own a pet or not is irrelevant to assessing diversity metrics.

Develop questions that are precise and unbiased. Provide inclusive options, such as non-binary choices for gender identity, and avoid assumptions that could alienate respondents. By prioritizing inclusivity, your organization can gather meaningful data that truly reflects its workforce.

Those are 10 helpful things to know when collecting employee data, but having the right tools can make all the difference. Pulsely’s Inclusive Culture Survey is a powerful solution designed to gather DEI-related data securely and effectively. It collects insights on inclusivity, employee engagement, and cultural alignment while maintaining compliance with privacy laws.

Ready to get actionable results, build a more equitable workplace, and foster employee trust? Book a demo or contact us to learn more!

‍

This blog post provides information for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Pulsely is not responsible for any decisions or actions taken based on the information in this article.

‍