Michael stared at his resignation letter for the third time that morning before finally hitting send. After two years at a company he once loved, he wasn't leaving for more money or a better title. He was leaving because of his manager. The limited development opportunities, lack of recognition, and poor communication had slowly eroded his enthusiasm until coming to work felt like a daily battle. "I can find another job," he thought, "but I can't spend another day with a manager who makes me feel invisible."

The old adage remains true: people don't leave companies—they leave managers. Research from McKinsey shows that manager relationships are the leading factor in employee turnover decisions. According to Gallup, managers account for at least 70% of the variance in employee engagement, and poor management is cited as the primary reason for leaving in exit interviews across industries.

As organizations face increasing pressure to retain top talent amid shifting workplace expectations, understanding the manager's role in employee retention has never been more critical. Let's explore the key reasons employees leave their managers and what organizations can do to address these issues before talent walks out the door.

Poor Communication Creates Uncertainty

When managers fail to communicate effectively, employees are left feeling confused, anxious, and disconnected. This communication breakdown manifests in several ways:

• Lack of clear expectations: Employees can't succeed when they don't know what success looks like
• Insufficient feedback: Without regular input on their performance, employees can't grow or adjust
• Information silos: Keeping team members in the dark about important decisions or changes creates distrust
• One-way communication: Managers who speak but don't listen miss valuable insights and make employees feel devalued

Harvard Business Review reports that communication deficiencies between managers and employees can reduce productivity by up to 25%.

Lack of Recognition and Appreciation

Human beings have a fundamental need to feel valued. When managers fail to recognize contributions or express appreciation, employees naturally question their worth to the organization.

Recognition doesn't always mean formal awards or monetary incentives. Often, the most meaningful recognition comes through:

• Specific, timely acknowledgment of good work
• Public appreciation in team settings
• Connecting individual contributions to larger team or company goals
• Taking time to understand and value unique perspectives and skills

These kinds of incentives are central to making employees feel appreciated.

Limited Growth and Development Opportunities

Career stagnation is a powerful push factor. When employees feel their manager isn't invested in their growth, they'll seek growth elsewhere. Managers hinder development when they:

• Fail to provide challenging assignments
• Don't make time for mentoring or coaching
• Ignore employees' career aspirations
• Hoard interesting projects rather than delegating
• View employee advancement as a threat rather than a success

Our data shows that employees who see a future with their organization are significantly more likely to stay.

Unfair Treatment and Favoritism

Nothing destroys team morale faster than the perception of unfairness. When managers show favoritism, apply policies inconsistently, or allow biases to influence decisions, employees lose faith in the system—and often choose to leave.

Common examples include:

• Assigning prime projects to favored team members
• Inconsistent enforcement of rules or policies
• Allowing certain employees privileges or freedoms others don't receive
• Showing bias in promotion or advancement opportunities

As we explored in our article about exclusion at work, perceived unfairness can be particularly damaging for members of underrepresented groups who may already face additional workplace barriers.

Leadership Accountability Gaps

When managers aren't held accountable for their leadership practices and behaviors, it creates a culture where employee retention inevitably suffers. Leadership accountability serves as the foundation for trust between managers and their teams.

Key accountability issues that drive employees away include:

• Diffused responsibility where everyone is theoretically responsible, but no one is specifically accountable
• Performance reviews that fail to incorporate leadership effectiveness metrics
• Inconsistent consequences for poor management practices
• Misaligned priorities that allow managers to revert to familiar but ineffective leadership habits

Without structured accountability frameworks, even well-intentioned leadership initiatives falter. As we explore in our article on using diversity and inclusion data for leadership accountability, organizations that implement consequential accountability measures see significantly faster progress in building inclusive environments where employees want to stay.

How Organizations Can Improve Manager Retention Capabilities

The good news is that management-driven turnover is preventable. Organizations that invest in developing their managers see demonstrably lower turnover rates. Here are concrete steps organizations can take to address these issues:

1. Invest in management training: Many managers are promoted for technical skills without proper leadership development
2. Create feedback loops: Regular pulse surveys and skip-level meetings can identify management issues before they cause turnover
3. Establish clear management expectations: Define and reward good people management, not just business results
4. Promote psychological safety: Encourage environments where employees can speak up without fear
5. Implement regular check-ins: Replace annual reviews with ongoing conversations about performance and development
6. Recognize and address biases: Provide unconscious bias training and review systems for fairness

The Bottom Line: The High Cost of Poor Management

The cost of replacing employees ranges from 50% to 200% of their annual salary, making manager-driven turnover an expensive problem.  Beyond financial implications, high turnover damages morale, disrupts teams, and creates a negative reputation that makes recruiting more difficult.

Deloitte research found that organizations with strong leadership development programs are 1.7 times more likely to be ranked among the top financial performers in their industries. By investing in management development and addressing the core issues that drive employees away, organizations can significantly improve retention, engagement, and overall performance.

Empower Your Managers with Pulsely

At Pulsely, we understand the critical role managers play in employee retention and organizational success. Our Inclusive Culture Survey helps develop leaders who inspire loyalty and bring out the best in their teams.

Our comprehensive approach includes:

• Real-time analytics that identify management blind spots before they lead to turnover
• Customizable surveys that capture nuanced feedback on manager performance
• Science-based recommendations that transform average managers into exceptional leaders
• Benchmarking tools that show how your management practices compare to industry standards

The most successful organizations recognize that manager development is not a one-time event but an ongoing process that requires the right tools and insights.

Ready to transform your managers into retention champions? Book a demo with Pulsely today and discover how our solutions can help you build a high-performing, engaging culture where top talent thrives.

‍